Goodbye, Map

On September 7, 2009 · 3 Comments

Admired objects are supposed to be handled with dignity. A good example is a flag which is accorded a certain respect as it fades, rips or otherwise reaches the end of its useful life. In the United States there’s even a federal law requiring that it "should be destroyed in a dignified way, preferably by burning." But what about a map? While I certainly wouldn’t equate a map with a national emblem, simply tossing it into the garbage doesn’t seem to be a fitting end either.

AAA Driving Map of North America

I divide my maps into two distinct categories: those that are collectibles that remain in pristine condition and those that are working documents that live a tough existence on the road as I travel. Here’s my dilemma. My primary working map, a 2001 version of the American Automobile Association’s AAA North American Road Atlas, remains solely on life-support at the moment. It’s been stuffed into suitcases, shoved under car seats, written on, rained on, ripped and torn, as its traveled from one end of a continent to the other. It has witnessed thousands of road miles and tens of thousands of air miles. It has performed the job brilliantly but it can’t absorb much more abuse.

I have a second problem. What should replace it? Have road atlases become obsolete? Are they the electric typewriters of the 21st Century? Buggy whips? Raccoon coats?

Garmin Nuvi Car GPS Screen

I’ve embraced modern navigating technology and obviously find onboard global positioning system tools indispensable. I’m partial to the Garmin Nüvi at the moment and have one stuck to the windshield whenever I take an extended roadtrip or even when I’m trying to find the exact spot of a local landmark. I programmed the longitude/latiutude coordinates into the Nüvi when I was trying to find the independent city highpoints last weekend as an example, and it certainly made the task simpler. I also selected simulation mode when I working on the U.S. Highway 183 entry for no particular reason other than natural curiosity, and you see the resulting image above. GPS is a great advance and its hard to remember how we managed without it, although certainly we did.

I don’t like the limitations of a small screen however, and I don’t like the prescribed nature of calculated routes. I deviate from what the Nüvi dictates frequently and for what I consider to be highly logical reasons. Unnatural reliance on a GPS device becomes a crutch that leads to stunningly bad driving choices. That screen on the dashboard doesn’t know which highways choke with traffic, which neighborhoods harbor petty criminals eying easy targets, or which secondary roads mask bone-jarring cattle ruts. Follow that Nüvi blindly though and you’ll experience all of those and more.

Plus there’s an annoying voice synthesizer that berates me when I choose a different driving option. She earned her nickname "yelling lady" when I entered a traffic circle (that’s a roundabout or rotary intersection for those of you in many parts of the world) and she couldn’t deal with rapid changes in geographic direction. Try listening to "recalculating" about a dozen times in rapid-fire succession while your kids are laughing their tails off in the back seat, and we’ll see if you’re not ready to chuck the device out the window.

And what’s up with the umlaut?

View Larger Map

Real-time GPS is by no means the only tool available. Online mapping services provide a great service too, albeit with much of their usefulness coming before the journey begins. I developed the map above for instance as I was preparing for my trip along Wisconsin’s portion of the Great River Road last summer. It was quick and easy.

The convergence between these mapping services and handheld devices evolves as GPS chips in mobile phones become a standard feature. This was apparent when I explored the implications more than a year ago and the trend only continues. The convergence offers some advantages. It’s easier to customize an exact route in Google Maps than with the clunky Nüvi interface, but screen size limitations on a handheld unit continue to limit its usefulness. It is difficult to see the Big Picture – quite literally – and take that into account while making decisions on the fly. Road conditions change in a heartbeat and flexibility is not optional for me.

DeLorme Driving Map of New York State

While I use and enjoy the technology I still need the dead tree equivalent. I will continue to pack a general paper map and often a more detailed special-purpose atlas until technology offers a complete and reliable alternative. It was a paper map that saved our hides on our recent trip up to Maine. The AAA atlas offered the solution, allowing us to select among the full set of possible alternative routes that were simply not visible on the tiny Nüvi screen. The Nüvi performed fine once we plotted the route and entered the proper landmarks into its memory, but until it kept wanting to route us back to the roadblock in the most efficient manner possible until we intervened manually. We’d probably still be sitting on that highway outside of Boston if we’d relied entirely on the Nüvi.

I’ve talked myself into replacing the paper atlas even though it’s purpose has changed over the last few years from primary navigation tool to emergency backup. I wonder if this will be the last time I replace it with paper. Perhaps in another eight years we’ll all have dash-mounted laptops with ubiquitous nationwide broadband connections that will combine the advantages of the paper maps with the navigational abilities of GPS devices. Only then will I no longer need my paper maps.

I still have the problem of how to dispose of my current map properly, though.

Something Totally Unrelated

I wanted to let everyone know that I finally got around to claiming the domain Right now it simply points to the longer URL you’ve come to expect and I’m not sure if I’m going to change all the pages over to the new domain or not. It might be more of a pain than it’s worth. This won’t have any impact on viewers who subscribe to the RSS feed using various news readers, but it should be easier for those who go directly to the URL or who want to refer people to the site. Now it’s as easy as saying "go to"

On September 7, 2009 · 3 Comments

3 Responses to “Goodbye, Map”

  1. Randolph Clark says:

    A GPS in a rental car routed us over a high bridge in Portland, OR. High bridges in my life equal panic attacks. Fortunately there was a last minute escape route.
    Other than that they’re great.

  2. ply says:

    Those DeLorme map books are great, although I tend to pick the Benchmark ones given the choice. Benchmark seems to haven’t had made it to the eastern states yet. Very nice for the west though. If only there was something equivalent for Canada!

    A map lover like you, but who hasn’t yet fallen for the dashboard GPS thing,

  3. Nelson says:

    “have one stuck to the windshield” In many places it’s illegal to attach opaque objects to the windshield. An internet search for ‘windshield gps’ should yield half-a-dozen articles. Maybe the ‘Map of the Future’ will be a heads-up display as big as the driver’s half of the windshield.

Comments are closed.

12 Mile Circle:
An Appreciation of Unusual Places
Don't miss an article -
Subscribe to the feed!

RSS G+ Twitter
RSS Twelve Mile Circle Google Plus Twitter
Monthly Archives
Days with Posts
September 2017
« Aug