Vulnerable to Invasion

On February 13, 2011 · 3 Comments

All our talk of invasions, mostly imagined, got me thinking about times the United States has actually been invaded. Oceans on either side certainly limit the possibilities and reduce the number of occurrences to a handful. How many times has the United States been invaded? As with much we discuss on the Twelve Mile Circle, the answer is a firm "it depends." Historical facts are not in question, it’s the definition of Invasion that varies amongst sources.

I’ll mention a few instances and let the Intertube masses decide. Feel free to add more if you like. Then I’ll talk about an oddball sort-of invasion in a little more detail.

View Larger Map

It’s probably unanimous that the United States was invaded by the United Kingdom during the War of 1812. Can I get an amen on that one? A British invasion force burned much of the U.S. capital, Francis Scott Key witnessed the bombardment of Fort McHenry and wrote the Start-Spangled Banner, Andrew Jackson won the Battle of New Orleans even thought the peace treaty had already been negotiated… I think most of us are aware of the basic iconography.

So the answer is that the United States has been invaded at least one time. Then it gets a bit sticky.

  • Revolutionary War. I have a hard time comprehending a British invasion of anything. They were living in sovereign territory, going about their daily lives when a group of upstarts fomented an uprising. The British were simply attempting to hold onto colonies they’d controlled for a century and a half. Did they suddenly become invaders upon the American’s Declaration of Independence? I’m not convinced.
  • Mexican-American War. Fighting moved onto locations that are part of the United States today but I think they were either Mexico territory proper or disputed lands at the time so it’s hard to categorize it as an invasion of U.S. soil.
  • Civil War. I think a case would support that Confederate army forays into Union territory such as the Antietam Campaign [my visit] and the Gettysburg Campaign should be considered invasions. The counterargument is that it wasn’t truly an invasion by a foreign army since the Confederacy wasn’t recognized as a nation either by the United States or by the international community. To me this is an instance where it walks like a duck and talks like a duck, strict definitions notwithstanding.
  • World War II. While often overlooked, I believe the Aleutian Islands Campaign could qualify as an invasion of the United States by Japan (versus Pearl Harbor which seems to be more of an "attack"). Japanese forces physically occupied the islands of Kiska and Attu. It took nearly a year for U.S. forces to dislodge them. I’ve seen sources that dismiss this claim because Alaska wasn’t a state at the time, it was a territory. Personally I find that ludicrous. That’s like saying the U.S. wasn’t attacked at Pearl Harbor because Hawaii was also a territory.

I’m sure there are others. What obvious ones am I missing?

View Larger Map

Then we get to the curious case of the invasion of Columbus, New Mexico in 1916. There are a number of reasons why it might not be considered an invasion from a technical perspective. Pancho Villa’s DivisiĆ³n del Norte certainly had all the hallmarks of an army. However, it was a belligerent force that did not represent the government of Mexico. Meanwhile the Mexican Revolution continued to rage. Villa had endured devastating loses in Mexico and saw easy pickings for resupply just over the border. He didn’t intend to capture U.S. territory. It seemed closer to an act of desperation or resentment than of conquest.

Acting on bad intelligence, Villa completely underestimated the troop strength of U.S. 13th Cavalry stationed at nearby Camp Furlong. Villa shot-up Columbus, killed a few people, burned some building, caused general confusion and mayhem, but he didn’t fare well once the U.S. Army understood what was happening. His quick raid turned into a full-blown battle and rout, with the Villistas at the receiving end of well-armed defenders with machine guns. They withdrew into Mexico, much worse for wear.

The aftermath is rather more significant. U.S. President Woodrow Wilson ordered General John J. Pershing to lead several thousand troops into Mexico in attempt to capture Villa. They wandered through Mexico for about a year and fought a few skirmishes. They never did capture Pancho Villa. However, this marked the birth of the mechanized U.S. army: they used motorized trucks to create supply lines and airplanes to scout positions. Pershing and his troops would use these same lessons when U.S. entered the First World War a few months later. In a sense, Pancho Villa provided a convenient training ground for a new style of warfare.

View Larger Map

New Mexico commemorates the invasion of Columbus at Pancho Villa State Park, on the site of the original Camp Furlong. They claim that "this was the only ground invasion of the continental U.S. since 1812." I’m not sure I’d go that far for all the reasons and scenarios described above. It’s still a remarkable curiosity and I’d love to visit it someday.

It seems unusual to name a park after a foreign aggressor — I imagine it would downright offensive in just about any other context (e.g., thinking back to the controversy at Ground Zero in New York City) — but I suppose Pancho Villa has transformed into one of those romanticized mythical figures, larger than life. His name is a bigger tourist draw than if they’d called it Camp Furlong State Park, I suppose.

On February 13, 2011 · 3 Comments

3 Responses to “Vulnerable to Invasion”

  1. Peter says:

    During the Civil War, there also was the Confederate commando raid on St. Albans, Vermont. In one sense it was more like an invasion than were battles like Gettysburg because the raiders came from over the Canadian border.

  2. Rick Nordstrom says:

    Don’t forget about the St. Alban’s Raid! On 19 Oct 1864, a band of Confederates who had taken refuge in Canada staged a raid into the sleepy town of St. Albans, Vermont. Granted, the invasion consisted primarily of three bank robberies and a proclamation by Confederate Lieutenant Bennett Young that, “This city is now in the possession of the Confederate States of America!”, but I would still consider it an invasion.—Vermont-and-the-Civil-War&id=3932454

  3. UPDATE (March 11, 2011) as reported by Reuters: "The mayor and police chief of a small town on the U.S.-Mexico border were among 11 suspects indicted for allegedly trafficking around 200 guns to Mexico, authorities said on Thursday. The U.S. Attorney’s office in New Mexico said the mayor of Columbus, Eddie Espinoza, the town’s police chief Angelo Vega, and village trustee Blas Gutierrez were among those arrested on an 84-count indictment."

Comments are closed.

12 Mile Circle:
An Appreciation of Unusual Places
Don't miss an article -
Subscribe to the feed!

RSS G+ Twitter
RSS Twelve Mile Circle Google Plus Twitter
Monthly Archives
Days with Posts
September 2017
« Aug