Suriname’s Disputed Borders

On September 7, 2010 · 1 Comments

This is Suriname. Take a look at its shape relative to its neighbors, Guyana and French Guiana. These are the three Guianas, all lined up in a tiny, tidy row on the northeast corner of South American along the Atlantic Ocean. Suriname was once Dutch Guiana, a colony of the Netherlands. Guyana was once British Guiana and part of the United Kingdom. French Guiana continues to be part of France, an overseas department (département d’outre-mer).



View Larger Map

It’s a confusing situation. All three are the single minuscule outposts of cultures not represented elsewhere on the continent: English; Dutch and French. All three share common roots as colonial beachheads that somehow clung to this faraway land where Spanish and Portuguese interests dominated. Layer these cultural and historical differences on colonial boundaries that were a bit fuzzy and somewhat subject to interpretation. It didn’t really matter much during colonial times because the nearly impenetrable tangle of the rainforest grew practically to the coast. It does matter today.

The half million citizens of Suriname would not necessarily agree with the map as Google draws it. Never mind that Google reflects the opinion of just about every other national and international organization. However, someone living in Paramaribo is likely to draw it a bit differently. This is how Suriname sees its boundaries:


Suriname According to Suriname
MZ Primary Health Care Suriname

Take a look at the southwest and southeast corners. Notice something a little extra? Suriname believes its border with Guyana extends to the New River while others believe it follows the Kutari-Curuni River. Likewise, Suriname believes its border with French Guiana extends all the way to the Marouini River rather than the Litani River. The dispute reaches into the territorial waters of the Atlantic although it’s been partially resolved so I won’t focus on that today. The disputed territories on land are shown on the map, below.


Suriname's Disputed Borders
Wikimedia Commons in the public domain

The southwestern disputed area with Guyana, sometimes called the New River Triangle, covers a territory of 6,000 square miles (~15,600 square kilometres), which is larger than the U.S. state of Connecticut. It’s a fairly recent dispute. The Corentyne River has long been an accepted boundary. Dutch officials, starting in the 1960’s and prior to Suriname’s independence, began suggesting that the New River was an upper part of the Corentyne instead of just another tributary.

If the New River is actually the dominant watercourse forming the upper portion of the Corentyne River, as the logic goes, then the existing boundary line is incorrect. It should shift from the Kutari-Curuni River to the New River in Surname’s favor.

A similar situation exists with respect to the French Guiana border. In this instance it’s the Marouini River and Litani River which are in question. One might wonder what the bother is all about in these very remote, sparsely inhabited interior jungles. Suriname is a small nation and territorial expansion would increase both its size and stature. The genuine possibility of gold, diamonds, bauxite and hydroelectric resources probably figure into the justification as well.

I reviewed several academic and legal descriptions of the situation. The consensus seems to be that Suriname would probably lose if it agreed to arbitration under the precepts of international law. The overarching evidence supporting the cases of its western and eastern neighbors is that both have occupied and governed the disputed areas as integral parts of their sovereign territory for more than a century.

It seems that Suriname will continue to print alternative maps for the foreseeable future but it won’t likely change the situation. The Suriname version of their national map will remain an interesting artifact.

geography

On September 7, 2010 · 1 Comments

One Response to “Suriname’s Disputed Borders”

  1. Matt says:

    Quebec still prints maps that try to reverse the Labrador boundary dispute of 1927: http://www.mcwetboy.net/maproom/2007/01/the_quebeclabra.php.

Comments are closed.

Purpose
12 Mile Circle:
An Appreciation of Unusual Places
Subscribe
Don't miss an article -
Subscribe to the feed!

RSS G+ Twitter
RSS Twelve Mile Circle Google Plus Twitter
Categories
Monthly Archives
Days with Posts
October 2017
S M T W T F S
« Sep    
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031