Schoolcraft Daze

Now where were we before I took off for a couple of weeks on my Riverboat Adventure? I believe I was discussing Henry Rowe Schoolcraft and various places named in his honor scattered through the Upper-Midwest of the United States, principally Michigan and Minnesota.

So I learned long ago that leaving things unsaid could be a risk. The 12MC audience has become increasingly adept at guessing where I’m heading. Reader comments often anticipate future topics. Sure enough, Twelve Mile Circle’s own County Counter Extraordinaire, Fritz Keppler, nailed it when he saidSchoolcraft also had his hand in naming a number of counties in Michigan, drawing on a variety of sources.”

I’d observed the same trend as each new Michigan county revealed itself in Every County.


The Schoolcraft Influence

Henry R Schoolcraft 1955. Beal Brothers, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

I’ll not talk much about the life of Schoolcraft since I discussed him in the prior article. Rather, I’ll focus on some of the placenames he coined. Schoolcraft created all sorts of pseudo-Indian neologisms by combining Native American words or phrases, often Ojibwe/Algonquin, with classic Greek, Latin or Arabic roots.

I first encountered Schoolcraft’s craft (I knew I had to work that in somewhere) in reference to Lake Itasca — the generally accepted source of the Mississippi River — quite a number of years ago. One of his traveling companions, the Rev. William T. Boutwell, told a story years after the fact about a canoe trip the two took together. Apparently Schoolcraft asked Boutwell how to say “headwaters” in various classic languages. However, Boutwell could remember only the Latin variant, veritas (truth) and caput (head).

So Schoolcraft discarded the first three letters from veritas and the last three from caput and coined Itasca. One source notedIt is lucky Mr. Boutwell did not think of the Greek for ‘head waters,’ or Itasca may have been named Lake Hydrocephalus.” Later, Schoolcraft recounted a completely concocted story tying Itasca to some Native American legend. Nonetheless the Boutwell explanation called him out on it.


The Counties

Ten Michigan counties reflected Schoolcraft’s neologisms. I attempted to determine their etymology although, frankly, maybe only Schoolcraft himself knew for sure. Some of the words or parts of words might have simply sounded “Indian enough” without further explanation necessary. I used Native American Placenames of the United States as a reference unless otherwise noted.

Alcona

The county itself said the name vaguely translated to “the fine and excellent plain” combining Arabic and two different Native American words. Also the county originally had a genuine Native name, “Negwegon,” a Chippewa chief. But apparently that wasn’t good enough so Schoolcraft created his own fake name.

Allegan

It may translate roughly from “Lake of the Algonquins” although I noticed other explanations floating around the Intertubes.

Alpena

A vaguely Native American word akin to “a good partridge country.”

Arenac

From “arena,” the Latin word for sand plus an Algonquian word for land. Sandy Land.

Iosco

Supposedly meaning “water of light.” Schoolcraft published stories based on various Native legends. Thus, Iosco was a name he coined for one of the heroes.

Kalkaska

Thought to be an Algonquin amalgamation for “burned over.”

Leelanau

For some odd reason, Schoolcraft often named Native American women Leelinau in the stories he published. Supposedly it meant “delight of life.”

Lenawee

Signifying “men” or “the people” and probably from the Shawnee “lenawai.”

Oscoda

The combination of two Ojibwa words, ossin meaning stone and muskoda meaning prairie.

Tuscola

Tusco meaning warrior or Tusci meaning level land are both possibilities.


Motivation

One wonders why Schoolcraft felt he needed to manufacture words when there were perfectly fine Native American options available. He probably thought he was performing a good deed, preserving vestiges of Native culture within familiar and palatable Old World wrappers. Certainly he felt a sense of cultural superiority:

“In 1832 he founded the Algic Society — the first use of his neologism that combined “Algonquian” and “Atlantic” — ‘for encouraging missionary efforts in evangelizing the north western tribes, and promoting education, agriculture, industry, peace and temperance, among them.’ By this time Schoolcraft openly subscribed to the popular belief that America’s aboriginal population was in a degenerate or ‘fallen,” moral state, but he also insisted that the data on language and legends that he was gathering and publishing indicated the Indians’ potential for salvation.”

I think that provided a succinct explanation. Schoolcraft’s sense of moral superiority — so common during that period in history — compelled him to reject Native American phrases in their undiluted form. So instead he created what he’d likely consider improvements.


Posted

in

,

by

Comments

One response to “Schoolcraft Daze”

  1. Drake T Avatar
    Drake T

    I know nothing of Schoolcraft beyond your writing and nothing of the general context of the quote pasted above, but I would like to suggest a little bit of caution in drawing too big of a conclusion on his opinions on cultural superiority. He may very well thought as you proposed, but basing that opinion strictly from the quote, “by this time Schoolcraft openly subscribed to the popular belief that America’s aboriginal population was in a degenerate or ‘fallen,’ moral state…” This word choice, even today, would be a fair summary of a good number of Christians who subscribe to the concept of Original Sin, that is to say the vast majority of what is considered mainstream Christianity. The common belief amongst most Christians (Catholics, Orthodox, many Protestants) is that man is “fallen” or in a state that requires salvation. This theological observation is in no way limited to North American aboriginals.
    Love the blog!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Comments

  1. Clint, 24 March 2021. I’m 89 years old and have traveled the 100th Meridian for years between Uvalde, TX and…

  2. Many of these comments are very interesting, have enjoyed reading. We cross several times a year as well going from…