Infrequent Crossings, US-Canada

On June 28, 2012 · 6 Comments

Twelve Mile Circle loves its borders, and probably none more than the border between Canada and the United States (for instance). The statistics are impressive: 119 border crossings; 39,254,000 trips by Canadians into the United States in 2009; and nearly $500 million in international trade passing every day on the Ambassador Bridge between Windsor, Ontario and Detroit, Michigan.

Those are great. I rather enjoy examining the other end of the spectrum even more. Not every crossing can be as popular as the Ambassador Bridge. What about some of the lesser-known ports of entry? Fortunately the U.S. Department of Transportation funds a Bureau of Transportation Statistics deep within the bowels of its bureaucracy, which offers a convenient Border Crossing/Entry Data website. Let’s take a peek.

First thing, I noticed that it’s difficult to determine which crossing might be the least popular. Should I count people, vehicles, cargo containers, or what? I decided to select a few choice categories and let them stand on their own rather than force apples-to-oranges scenarios. All figures were compiled from the perspective of the United States government for the year 2011.

It’s important to note that these are all the lowest non-zero values. Most ports of entry lack train traffic as an example. Zero values were excluded from my search.

View Larger Map

Fewest Trains (25th place) – Calais, Maine International Avenue / New Brunswick. This border crossing recorded 77 trains. There are train tracks in the immediate area although I can’t seem to find where they cross the border. Does anyone know how this works? Does the train cross elsewhere and then check-in at Calais because that’s the closest location that’s staffed by border officials? Why did they record so few trains?

Fewest Train Passengers (25th place) – Laurier, Washington / Cascade, British Columbia. This is why it’s so difficult to draw comparisons between categories or in aggregate. One would expect a correlation between trains and train passengers, however that overlooks the simple fact that many trains haul freight exclusively. Thus the place with the fewest cross-border train passengers traversing the border takes place on the other side of the North American continent.

Fewest Trucks (79th place) – Ferry, Washington / Midway, British Columbia. A grand total of three trucks crossed there in 2011. That’s one truck every four months. I imagine that this would be a very poor choice for a smuggler. Trucks are so rare that it’s an event. I bet customs agents scrutinize them intensely just to have an opportunity to do something a little different. It’s not hard to see why trucks don’t generally pass through here. It’s a little out the way and several larger, more truck-friendly roads cross the border to the east and west.

View Larger Map

Fewest Buses (3-way tie for 64th place) – Pinecreek, Minnesota / Piney Manitoba, Bridgewater, Maine / Centreville, New Brunswick, and Hannah, North Dakota / Snowflake, Manitoba. Each of these locations recorded a single bus. That’s right, only one bus passed each of these locations in all of 2011.

I wonder if this included a bus full of geo-oddity tourists on the way to see the bi-national airport runway at Pinecreek?

View Larger Map

Fewest Pedestrians (43rd place) – Noonan, North Dakota / Estevan, Saskatchewan. Seriously, I’d love to know the story behind the single pedestrian who crossed here. Just look at the Street View image. It’s remote. It’s empty. Why would anyone be walking through here and where would they be going?

View Larger Map

Fewest Personal Vehicles (85th place) – Whitlash, Montana / Aden, Alberta. This might be my favorite proxy measure for the least popular border crossing. Passenger vehicles are by far the most common way to cross between the two nations. Only 656 used Whitlash in an entire year. Two per day. Wow. I’d probably cross here if I were in the area just to inflate their statistics.

Foreshadowing. I’ll perform a similar exercise on the U.S. – Mexico border in the next installment.

Totally Unrelated. Remember Pinwheel? I just received another batch of invitations for their private beta. Let me know if you’d like one and I’ll send it to an email address of your choice.

On June 28, 2012 · 6 Comments

6 Responses to “Infrequent Crossings, US-Canada”

  1. Not far from my neck of the woods is the old border crossing at Flathead, BC/MT. It was closed in 1994, and if you look at where it is on a map, you can probably understand why. I imagine it probably held many of the records on this list before then.

  2. Karl Z says:

    The reason for the fewest trains at Calais, Maine/Milltown, New Brunswick: the tracks you see are mostly an out-of-service branch line from Brewer to Calais. Only the extreme eastern end is operated by Pan Am Railways, interchanging loads from a pulp mill with the New Brunswick Southern Railway in Canada. They only run about once a week, as needed, so that’s why only 77 “trains” show up here. It’s basically an industrial switching move. The operable portion of the branch is isolated from the rest of the US system, so it’s only connection is at Calais, and only through Canada. The connection is about a mile north and slightly east of the point you show on the map. (The branch line crosses over to the New Brunswick shore about two miles south of the road crossing you show, runs up that side of the river to Woodland, then crosses back over to serve the plant. The interchange with the New Brunswick Southern is in Calais at Milltown Railway Bridge. Google Maps shows this bridge as being disconnected, but it isn’t…apparently…)

    As for the customs side of things…the whole thing is isolated from the rest of the US rail system, so the only place the pulp loads can go is Canada. I don’t know for sure, but I suspect that any clearances are done at the pulp mill before shipment. It makes life a lot easier that way.

  3. David says:

    Are you out of pinwheel invites? I would love one!
    Thanks for the GREAT FREAKING WORK.

    Any possibilities that you’ll write a mid-summer, geography and geo-oddity nerds reading list? Or even a winter version of this?

    • Thanks David — an invitation is on its way. I’ll have to think about what I’d put on a reading list. I read voraciously although to be honest it’s mostly online stuff or maps.

  4. Scott says:

    It’s too bad that the BTS site doesn’t include statistics on the Goat Haunt port of entry. Only US and Canadian citizens are allowed to pass through (but if you aren’t, you are still allowed to do a 1/4 mile hike!), and the only way to get there is by boat or hike. There are numerous websites with reports and stories about this port of entry, but here’s an official one:

Comments are closed.

12 Mile Circle:
An Appreciation of Unusual Places
Don't miss an article -
Subscribe to the feed!

RSS G+ Twitter
RSS Twelve Mile Circle Google Plus Twitter
Recent Comments
Monthly Archives
Days with Posts
September 2017
« Aug