Google Maps County Lines on the Way?

On May 17, 2011 · 8 Comments

Are county boundaries finally on the way to Google Maps? County Counters including myself have bemoaned the complete lack of county lines in Maps, having to rely on Mapquest and other sources instead. Last night, however, I went to Google and searched on Fayette County, Pennsylvania. I was shocked to see the result.


Fayette County Pennsylvania Map

Check it out! That’s an imbedded image of Fayette County within the Google search results, in the familiar Google Maps format. How long has that feature been there? I’m a fairly heavy user and that’s the first time I’ve seen it. I clicked on the image and it carried me to Maps, but once I landed there the county lines disappeared again. That seemed odd.



View Larger Map

Someday, maybe someday county lines will appear in the image I imbedded above. That’s not the case as of May 2011 though.

I went back to the Google search engine results and started plugging-in random county names. It seemed that perhaps 60% of counties displayed with similar maps. The others county names produced no map at all. It also seemed to produce results for many states but not all, leading me to believe that I may have stumbled across some kind of work in progress. Google probably isn’t ready to roll it out publicly but clearly something is being tested.

Maybe Google is listening. More than a year ago, all the way back in February 2010, I posted an article called Let’s Get County Lines Drawn on Google Street View. I’d noticed that Google had a page called Suggest a Feature for Maps. People could select several options including one called "Show county boundaries on the map" with a button labeled "Suggest It." I asked people to click the button and many of you did. The button still works so if you haven’t suggested it previously, please take a moment and give them a little encouragement to continue with their effort. If you tried this last year, well, why don’t you go ahead and try it again? I did. Let’s see if we can push their test into production.

I’ve often wondered why those lines haven’t been added yet. No, I don’t lead a very exciting life. I have a couple of theories and maybe you do too. First, we know that state and even national boundaries in Google Maps can be off by anywhere from a few feet to perhaps a hundred. Maybe they’ve had trouble overlaying all of the counties with a decent level of precision? Is that why they will only show them as an imbedded image in a search? On the other hand, they’ve long had a county border layer in Google Earth apparently without precision issues so it shouldn’t be too difficult to recycle the same data file.

Second, and I know this will shock the county counting community, but maybe Google doesn’t think their users are all that interested in county lines. Maybe Google doesn’t want to clutter their maps? However, Mapquest also targets the general populace and they don’t seem to have any county line concerns. Also I can’t believe it wouldn’t be more popular than some Google Map options. How many people really use the webcam feature?

I’ve been stumped. Now I’m encouraged. Google has started displaying county lines even if it’s still rather limited. Can a county line feature within Google Maps itself be far behind? If it happens… remember you heard it on 12MC, first!

On May 17, 2011 · 8 Comments

8 Responses to “Google Maps County Lines on the Way?”

  1. Denverist says:

    I’ve also noticed that when I search for a city, the first result now includes an embedded image with city limits. My guess as to why some searches show an embedded image with county limits while others don’t has to do with ambiguity. I searched for Lee County, NC and Orange County, NC and a map didn’t appear. (According to Wikipedia, there are 12 Lee Counties and 8 Orange Counties in the US.) Meanwhile, a search for Stanly County (the only one in the US) produced a map with county limits.

  2. Denverist says:

    Our Google overlords continue to disappoint us…

  3. Fritz Keppler says:

    I’m also looking forward to their incorporating county lines into their regular maps. Some day, some day…

  4. Marc Alifanz says:

    County lines would be a very welcome addition to google maps.

  5. Keith Baumgart says:

    It’s probably due to Google Mapmaker.

  6. Oil & Gas Mineral Rights Consultant says:

    I have had to use Mapquest because it shows county lines! I sure Google would hurry up. Sometimes, someone sends me a custom Google map they have created and I can’t see the county lines and that’s not good for me!

  7. Barry says:

    Just found the same thing that you described above…county boundaries show up in the thumbnail image that appears with search results, but then disappear once I click through to the larger map. So, still no fix as of Oct. 2011

Comments are closed.

Purpose
12 Mile Circle:
An Appreciation of Unusual Places
Subscribe
Don't miss an article -
Subscribe to the feed!

RSS G+ Twitter
RSS Twelve Mile Circle Google Plus Twitter
Categories
Monthly Archives
Days with Posts
September 2017
S M T W T F S
« Aug    
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930