Alternate Rhode Islands

On May 27, 2012 · 7 Comments

Something has to be the smallest. Most of us, or at least those of us in the 12MC audience from the United States, probably know that Rhode Island claims this honor for the U.S. Exactly how small is it though? One hears frequently of individual counties within the United States as being "larger than Rhode Island." It’s certainly true but is it a rare occurrence or is it something altogether more common?

View Larger Map

Little Rhody makes up for its diminutive size by having a much longer official name though, "Rhode Island and Providence Plantations." Some might consider that a bit of a Napoleon Complex although the truth is rather mundane. The name represents the merger of two predecessor colonies, so take heart that Rhode Island could have been even smaller than it is today. Rhode Island formed after the banishment of Roger Williams from the Massachusetts Bay Colony due to religious differences in 1636. Tucked into a corner as it were, Rhode Island didn’t have the same opportunities to gather or solidify territorial claims further west. It became even more of an outlier as the new nation formed and expanded to the Pacific.

Rhode Island encompasses 1,214 square miles (3,144 square kilometers). Actually, I’m being generous since that calculation also includes its territorial waters. If one were to examine only dry land it would cover only 1,045 square miles. However, for the sake of comparison, I wanted to give Rhode Island the full benefit of the doubt and chose to inflate its size to the largest plausible number.

From there it was pretty easy to consult the U.S. Census Bureau’s American FactFinder where I downloaded square mileage and population numbers for each of the 3,143 individual counties and county-equivalents. I knew Rhode Island was small but I didn’t realize just how small it was until I calculated the results and created a map. There are an astounding 504 counties in the U.S. that are larger than Rhode Island. That total would jump to 622 counties if I considered only Rhode Island’s dry land.

U.S. Counties Larger than Rhode Island

Rhode Island — including its territorial waters — is smaller than each of the counties marked in red. Practically every county west of the Great Plains is larger. There are others scattered around the eastern half of the nation including one that actually borders on Rhode Island itself: Worcester County, Massachusetts (map).

I’ve not calculated this as a percentage of the overall United States landmass although it’s safe to say it’s considerable. Eyeballing it I’d conclude the larger counties cover somewhere between a third to a half of the Lower 48 states. Throw in Alaska where only a tiny handful of boroughs are smaller than Rhode Island, and I’ll bet it represents at least half of all U.S. acreage.

You can open that image within another tab or window if you’d like to take a closer look. I’ve shrunk it down to fit into the size limitations of this article even though the underlying graphics file is considerably larger.

This got me thinking about "Alternate Rhode Islands." Surely, the preponderance of larger counties contain thousands of empty acres with nary a soul living amongst them. It’s unfair to compare Kenedy County, Texas and its 416 residents (which we’ve discussed before) to Rhode Island’s population of 1,052,567, as an example. Let’s set those sparsely-settled counties aside.

I still felt that there were probably a decent set of counties both larger than Rhode Island and greater in population. A quick data sort revealed a dozen instances. Each of these could easily become a standalone state based upon Rhode Island criteria. I’ve also proposed a potential capital city for each of these fictional states:

Potential State … Derived from … Capital City … 2010 Population
Los Angeles California Los Angeles 9,818,605
Harris Texas Houston 4,092,459
Maricopa Arizona Phoenix 3,817,117
San Diego California San Diego 3,095,313
Miami-Dade Florida Miami 2,496,435
Riverside California Riverside 2,189,641
San Bernardino California San Bernardino 2,035,210
Clark Nevada Las Vegas 1,951,269
King Washington Seattle 1,931,249
Santa Clara California San Jose 1,781,642
Bexar Texas San Antonio 1,714,773
Palm Beach Florida West Palm Beach 1,320,134

Additionally, I could add a couple of counties that are " near misses" with populations just below Rhode Island: Pima County, Arizona and Fresno County, California.

I then added a final dimension in an attempt to determine which of these counties were most like Rhode Island in terms of population density. Rhode Island has about 867 people per square mile. Some of the counties had considerably greater population densities. Los Angeles and Harris both had nearly triple the density of Rhode Island. Imagine the behemoth of a state either one of those could become should they ever split away.

The best Rhode Island proxies are King and San Diego. King is probably the better example. It comes quite close to being of similar size and population to Rhode Island. I’ll bear that in mind the next time I’m in Seattle. It could legitimately anchor another Rhode Island-like state.

On May 27, 2012 · 7 Comments

7 Responses to “Alternate Rhode Islands”

  1. Peter says:

    Note that despite its size, Texas has relatively few larger-than-Rhode Island counties, due of course to its vast number of counties.

  2. Fritz Keppler says:

    Although Brewster County TX has for a long time bragged that it is bigger than Connecticut.

    (Been away for a while, on another county line collecting trip, 321 new ones, also to see the eclipse in Albuquerque.)

  3. Fritz Keppler says:

    (Also tried to get to the Sandoval County exclave, but the BIA road to it from NM 4 was closed, supposedly due to fire damage)

  4. Gary says:

    I live in Florida now, but I was born in and lived the first 38 years of my life in Rhode Island. Not far from where I live in Florida are two of the larger than RI counties, Osceola and Polk, which also border each other. Florida as it turns out has six counties that are larger than RI. Living up there all my life, it seemed weird when I moved here and realized that counties are such a large part of government, as in the rest of the country too. I get weird looks when I say “pahk the cah in the yahd” the New England way. 🙂

Comments are closed.

12 Mile Circle:
An Appreciation of Unusual Places
Don't miss an article -
Subscribe to the feed!

RSS G+ Twitter
RSS Twelve Mile Circle Google Plus Twitter
Monthly Archives
Days with Posts
October 2017
« Sep