Smallest County in the USA, Part 2

The previous article discussed why Kalawao County, Hawaii may not really be the smallest county in the United States. Essentially, it’s not actually a county except in name only. So let’s examine the next smallest counties by area, New York County in New York and Bristol in Rhode Island. As it turns out, they are similarly problematic.


New York County, New York

View from Lower Manhattan. Photo by howderfamily.com; (CC BY-NC-SA 2.0)
View from Lower Manhattan

If you are to believe no less of an authority than the beverage company Snapple and their Real Fact #146, you might ponder what they’ve published on the inside of countless ice tea lids: “The smallest county in America is New York County, better known as Manhattan.” This is flat-out wrong. If New York County functions as a distinct entity then so does Kalawao County, which is clearly smaller. At 22.96 square miles, New York County is indeed small. But it’s not the smallest (map).

New York County is roughly analogous to Manhattan along with Roosevelt Island plus some outlying spots. It is part of an 1898 city-county consolidation that created a unified New York City with five boroughs. Of course those famously include The Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens and Staten Island. Officials sometimes described this as a sui generis arrangement (“one that is of its own kind”). So it is truly a unique structure in the United States.

The New York City Charter governs New York County; the county doesn’t act independently. The 1898 consolidation did create the office of Borough President which until recently had a meaningful influence on city budgets and land use. However the United States Supreme Court declared this unconstitutional in 1989 in Board of Estimate of City of New York v. Morris. Basically the Court held that the arrangement violated the “one man, one vote” doctrine due to population differences between the boroughs. Today the Borough President serves in a largely powerless advocacy position.

Therefore one can logically conclude that New York County is a non-governing entity within greater New York City. Manhattan is no doubt one of the most meaningful and influential places on the planet. Nonetheless, New York County became a county without stature.


Bristol County, Rhode Island

Beautiful Downtown Bristol, Rhode Island. Photo by J. Stephen Conn; (CC BY-NC 2.0)
Bristol, Rhode Island

So now we must move onto the next larger county. Let’s see if it is the right candidate or just another plot of land masquerading as a county. That takes the search to Bristol County, Rhode Island (map) with a landmass of 24.68 miles.

It is a pretty clear-cut case. Rhode Island disestablished its county structure. Both the Office of the Secretary of State of Rhode Island and the National Association of Counties confirmed this. Instead, it now has 39 self-governing municipalities.

The county structure still exists for purposes of the census and for other minor non-governing functions. For example, Bristol recorded about 50,000 residents in the most recent count. Otherwise it’s a historical artifact and simply a geographic designation. Three self-governing towns fill the borders of what was once Bristol County: Barrington; Warren; and the Town of Bristol. By definition it is a meaningless county.

So now we’ve examined the three smallest and most likely possibilities. Yet, we still have no definitive choice for what we might call the “smallest county in the United States.”

Other Posts in this Series:

Comments

2 responses to “Smallest County in the USA, Part 2”

  1. Gary Avatar

    I was born and bred in Rhode Island, and can vouch for the lack of county government. My guess is because the state is so small (something like 40 miles from top to bottom). I think the state had like five counties. Where I lived was in the town of North Kingstown in Washington County (known as South County to people up there). Washington is the most common name for a county in the country. 30 states (and a parish in Louisiana) have a Washington County. As we know, there is also a state called Washington and of course Washington DC. I now live in Florida, and we have a Washington County (in the panhandle in Central Time – mentioned in another article). https://www.howderfamily.com/blog/florida-time-change/

  2. Phil B Avatar
    Phil B

    According to Wikipedia, Kalawao County encompasses a total area of 53 sq. miles. New York County is 33.77 sq. miles, or about 19 sq. miles smaller than Kalawao. This of course includes all jurisdictional territory, i.e. water and land. Maps will typically include boundaries over both water and land. So, based on the typical definition of area using boundary measurement, New York County is indeed smaller than Kalawao County.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Comments

  1. Clint, 24 March 2021. I’m 89 years old and have traveled the 100th Meridian for years between Uvalde, TX and…

  2. Many of these comments are very interesting, have enjoyed reading. We cross several times a year as well going from…